Why The Eagles Were Wary of Becoming Too Popular Too Fast
via @TechGuy-jm1pd / YouTube
The Eagles stand as one of the most iconic rock bands in history, with a legacy of chart-topping hits, Grammy wins, and millions of albums sold. Yet, despite their rapid rise to fame in the 1970s, the band expressed unease about becoming too widely adored. To them, mass popularity carried risks, both artistic and personal.
Glenn Frey and Don Henley, along with their bandmates, wrestled with the idea of how much commercial success should influence their music. While many artists would have welcomed the widespread adoration they received, The Eagles wanted to preserve a sense of authenticity and individuality. For them, popularity was a double-edged sword.
Their reservations highlight a broader tension many successful artists face: how to balance fame and recognition with the deeper desire to make music that matters. The Eagles’ journey shows just how complex that balance can be.
The Desire to Stay Underdogs
From their debut album, The Eagles experienced remarkable success, with three songs landing in the Top 40. While this would typically be cause for celebration, Glenn Frey saw it differently. He viewed mass appeal with suspicion, arguing that wide public adoration often meant compromising artistic integrity. In his view, success could come at the cost of depth and meaning.
“Mass appeal is definitely suspect,” Frey once told Rolling Stone. He believed that simplifying music to appeal to the largest possible audience risked diluting its authenticity. For Frey, being popular for the wrong reasons was worse than not being popular at all.
Don Henley, however, saw things a bit differently. He pointed to artists like Paul Simon and Joni Mitchell, who managed to sell millions while staying true to their artistry. Even so, Frey remained determined to avoid creating music just for the sake of sales.
View this post on Instagram
Wrestling With the Price of Success
As their career progressed, The Eagles became increasingly aware of the burden that came with success. Bernie Leadon noted that the pressures of touring and recording often drained the creative spark that had once come so naturally. For the band, success sometimes felt like an obstacle to genuine artistic expression.
They even wove their frustrations into their songs. Tracks like “After the Thrill is Gone” served as coded critiques of the music business, thinly disguised as love songs. Beneath the polished sound, there was often commentary on the toll fame had taken on them.
Don Henley admitted that success transformed their passion into a profession, one that demanded more than a typical nine-to-five job. Music became a 24-hour responsibility, with the lifestyle burning them out faster than they could recover. Yet, as Joe Walsh memorably put it, burning the candle at both ends meant twice the light, even if it came at half the time.
Confidence Amid the Conflict
Despite their ambivalence about fame, The Eagles did not dismiss their achievements outright. Don Henley, for example, expressed pride that the band had successfully released three albums, noting that it solidified their place in the rock world. Even with their doubts, they knew they were part of something significant.
Henley also acknowledged the inevitability of their continued success. Regardless of their inner conflicts, he recognized that any album they released was likely to reach gold status within weeks. Their fan base was too strong, and their songwriting too sharp, for them not to thrive.
In the end, The Eagles’ wariness of success never overshadowed their confidence in their craft. They may have worried about being “too popular too fast,” but they still managed to strike a balance—making music that resonated deeply with listeners while staying mindful of the pitfalls of mass appeal.
